๐ Session 20 โ How Education Systems Fail Neurodivergent Kids
๐ฟ Transformative Education for Neurodivergent Liberation
"Education either functions as an instrument which is used to facilitate integration of the younger generation into the logic of the present system and bring about conformityโฆ or it becomes the practice of freedom, the means by which men and women deal critically and creatively with reality and discover how to participate in the transformation of their world."
โ Paulo Freire, Pedagogy of the Oppressed
๐ If youโre just joining us, I recommend reading [Session 1 โ Why Iโm Leading This Workshop (My Positionality)] for shared agreements and to understand how this space is held.
๐ฏ๏ธ A Note Before We Begin
Let me be clear: By institutional standards, Iโm not an educator. Iโm not a researcher in this area. And Iโm not a parent whoโs โfigured it all out.โ
But by humanistic standardsโI am all of these things.
Iโm a former studentโgifted, unsupported, often misunderstood. And a parentโwho has watched the school system fail both of my children in real time.
Iโm also a current graduate student in Transformative Social Change at a humanistic institution. I know what it looks like when education is done rightโbecause Iโm living proof it can be.
So this session isnโt about giving advice. Itโs about telling the truth from where I standโand inviting you to do the same.
๐ The One Year I Was Seen
In first grade, I was identified as gifted. I was reading at a sixth-grade level. Finishing assignments before the class even got started. For one yearโI was engaged. Challenged. Seen.
Then we moved. And moved again. And again.
Five elementary schools later, the gifted label was a ghostโsomething no one followed up on.
Because in working-class families, giftedness isnโt a golden ticket. Itโs a detour. There were no enrichment programs. No consistent support. Just a smart kid trying to adaptโand getting quieter, faster, more confused about why everything still felt so hard.
๐ฉโ๐ฆ Watching the System Fail My Kids
Both of my children are Neurodivergent, undeniably so. But we didnโt know that then.
What we did know was this: They were smart. Curious. Insightful. But school didnโt fit.
Theyโd do the homeworkโand not turn it in. Theyโd get bored, zone out, disengageโthen light up in spaces where they felt safe.
Again and again, we were told:
โTheyโre not meeting their potential.โ
But it wasnโt about motivation. It wasnโt even about learning style. It was about survival.
Their sophomore year of high school was the breaking pointโnot academically, but socially. That year took a toll on their spirit. Their sense of belonging. Their sense of self.
We didnโt have the words then. Just the weight of watching it happen. And when they dropped out, I didnโt argue.
They passed the GED without studying. And I knew:
It was never about ability. It was about environment.
If I could do it againโand had the economic privilegeโI would have unschooled them. And they agree.
๐ฏ๏ธ No Diagnosis Needed to Be Seen
This one is personal. Maybe more than most.
Neither of my sons are formally diagnosed. And yet, they are undeniably neurodivergent.
Theyโve chosen not to pursue diagnosisโand I respect that. We donโt need a label or a piece of paper to believe what we already know: their minds are beautiful, complex, sensitive, brilliant.
As their parent, my job is not to name them. Itโs to love them. To support them. To co-create an environment where they can name themselves.
But that hasnโt always been easy.
The world has opinions. Loud ones.
People have told meโrepeatedlyโthat by 22, they should be farther along. That theyโre too smart not to go to college. That they should be able to work full time. That they need more โstructure,โ more โdiscipline,โ more โmotivation.โ
All of it echoes the same old lie:
If youโre not producing or performing in ways the system rewards, something must be wrong with you.
But what if nothing is wrong with them? What if whatโs wrong is the system?
We are a family barely scraping by in a capitalist hellscape. And weโre also a family rooted in care, creativity, and mutual respect. We use our strengths to survive, our resilience to imagine, and our love to resist.
Neuronormativity and ableism knock on our door every day. But we answer with truth. With refusal. With softness.
And with the reminder: You do not need to be diagnosed to be deserving.
๐ What No One Talks About: When Parents and Young Adults Discover Their Neurodivergence Together
Thereโs a quiet revolution happening in so many homesโand almost no one is talking about it.
Families like mine, where parents and young adults are both discovering their neurodivergence at the same time.
Where weโre sitting across from each other at the kitchen table, finally understanding things that never made sense before. The meltdowns. The shutdowns. The school avoidance. The deep inner world that no one else ever saw.
We are not just processing diagnosesโweโre grieving years of erasure. Weโre unraveling the shame, the gaslighting, the high expectations that never matched the support.
And weโre doing it without any meaningful help.
Even if my children got a diagnosis tomorrowโthereโs nothing waiting for them. No formal support. Few community options. No clear pathway forward.
I know this because Iโve tried.
I spent two years in vocational rehab. Two years. Iโve had one interview.
I sat in those so-called "consumer meetings" and told the truth. I shared my access needs. I named the barriers.
And every other Autistic person (yes most of us where Autistic) in the room echoed back:
โI feel seen. Someone finally said it out loud.โ
We were honest. We were specific. And we were ignored.
Still, no changes. Still, no accommodations. Still, Iโm being sent through the same tired cycleโjob developers, rรฉsumรฉ writers, empty pep talks.
And Iโm supposed to be grateful? Grateful for what?
You didnโt help me. You wasted my time. You exploited my laborโand my kindness.
This is what so many of us are facing. Neurodivergent familiesโwhole systems of brillianceโbarely scraping by in a society that pretends to care but offers nothing in return.
We are not broken. The systems are.
๐งฌ Mapping Educational Harm Through the Cognitive Ecology Model (CEM)
CEM helps us see what the education system often refuses to: That โfailure to thriveโ in school is not a personal failure. Itโs a patterned response to an environment that was never built for neurodivergent minds.
Letโs look at how educational harm plays out across all five layers of CEM:
๐ Individual Layer (Self)
Internalized shame for โnot trying hard enoughโ or being โlazyโ when executive functioning was the real challenge.
Deep confusion when giftedness coexists with struggleโbecause no one teaches you that brilliance can look uneven.
Early identity formation around being โtoo sensitive,โ โtoo disruptive,โ or โnot living up to your potential.โ
๐ฑ Relational Layer (Interpersonal)
Constant correction or behavioral discipline instead of curiosity and support.
Teachers interpreting shutdowns as defiance.
Peers misunderstanding stimming, literal communication, or intense focusโleading to bullying, isolation, or social exclusion.
๐๏ธ Institutional Layer (Education Systems)
IEPs and 504 plans that donโt account for complexityโor are only accessible if you have a formal diagnosis.
Gifted programs that exclude 2E (twice-exceptional) students or mask their support needs.
Punitive grading systems that reward compliance over cognitionโand miss entire ways of learning.
๐บ Cultural Layer (Norms, Media, Messaging)
Stereotypes that say โsmart kids do well in schoolโ and โbad kids donโt care.โ
Pathologizing labels like โproblem child,โ โunderachiever,โ or โclass clown.โ
Erasure of Autistic, ADHD, and disabled excellence in curriculum, stories, and role models.
๐งฑ Structural Layer (Policy + Capitalism)
School funding tied to performance and attendance, not actual learning or well-being.
Surveillance-based behavior management systems.
Rigid schedules, standardized testing, and โzero toleranceโ policies that disproportionately harm neurodivergent and BIPOC students.
๐ฑ From โWhy Canโt They Learn?โ to โWhat Are We Missing?โ
CEM shifts the question from: โWhy doesnโt this kid fit the system?โ to โWhy is the system so narrow in its definition of intelligence, participation, and potential?โ
Because once we name the pattern, we can begin to change it.
๐ฅ This Is Where My Rage Lives
If youโre wondering where my fire comes fromโthis is it.
This is where I carry my deepest systemic rage.
Because this is where the betrayal begins. Not in adulthood. Not in the workplace. But hereโin childhood. In the places that were supposed to nourish us. That are supposed to see our kids. That are supposed to see us.
This is where the breakdown starts for so many families. This is where neurodivergent minds are first misread, mislabeled, misunderstood. This is where weโre manipulated into silence. Where compliance is mistaken for well-being. Where the system gaslights, punishes, and extractsโwhile calling it care.
And it doesnโt stop with school.
It follows us into adulthood, into vocational rehab, into bureaucratic dead ends that offer no real helpโjust delay, denial, and disrespect.
You want to know what erodes hope? Itโs not just unmet needs. Itโs being told over and over that the system is doing its bestโwhile your reality says otherwise.
My rage is sacred. Because itโs not just mineโit belongs to every child who was failed. Every parent who begged for help and got a pamphlet. Every neurodivergent person whose brilliance was pathologized, whose needs were ignored, whose humanity was measured in data points instead of dignity.
We are not here to be grateful for scraps. We are not broken. We are survivors of a system that breaks itself on our refusal to conform.
So yes, I am angry.
And I will stay angryโuntil our rage becomes repair.
But from that rage, we will riseโwith language, with clarity, and with each other. Because the truth has always lived in us. And together, weโre learning how to speak it.
๐ Reflection Invitation
This isnโt just my storyโitโs ours. The failures of the education system are not isolated incidents; they are patterned, predictable, and preventable. If this session stirred something in youโgrief, clarity, rageโI invite you to stay with it. Let it speak.
In the spirit of workshop integrity, vulnerability must be met with shared meaning-making. So letโs continue this conversation.
โจ What was your experience in school?
โจ Where were you failedโand what would support have looked like?
โจ What do you wish someone had known, asked, or done?
Your truth belongs here. Whether you write, speak, draw, or sit in silenceโyour way of showing up is welcome. Letโs name the harm, hold each other through it, and imagine something betterโtogether.
๐ฎ Whatโs Next:
๐ซ New Sessions Every Monday & Wednesday
This 12-week journey unfolds twice a weekโevery Monday and Wednesdayโwith each session building on the last.
You can view the full session lineup here, and hereโs whatโs coming next:
โจ Session 21 โ Interdependence is a Birthright
Weโll explore how the myth of independence harms us allโand why reclaiming interdependence is essential for collective liberation, especially for disabled, neurodivergent, and multiply marginalized communities.
๐ฌ Share Your Reflections
This space thrives when we co-create it. Your insights, stories, and resonances deepen the collective learning. Youโre invited to share in the comments or send a private message if that feels safer.
๐ Support the Work
This series is freely offeredโbecause healing and justice should never be paywalled.
If youโre in a position to support financially, a paid subscription helps sustain this labor and expands the reach of The Compassion Collectiveโa community grounded in equity, care, and transformation.
Every share, every response, every ripple of resonance helps keep this alive.
With gratitude,
๐ฟ Shamani of The Compassion Collective
Your ability to communicate your experience in its layered complexity astounds me! I am inspired by transformative education for neurodivergent liberation.
Now for my story. As an elementary school student in a small classroom setting, I learned well. In high school, my curiosity and interests were no longer aligned with the curriculum, and I went with my interests over performance and achievement.
My interests sere in Eastern knowledge practices and they were not taught, so I engaged in self study, practiced yoga and became a vegetarian (which was uncommon in the 1970's for a girl from a working class family). Anyway, I did well enough in school- but not as well as I could have if I was interested and connected to the teachers and teachings. But I made some good friends and did not struggle, went to college and had no idea what to do there, so I entered the program in Paris and studied there for two semesters. That's where I was introduced to a lifestyle that made sense to me - which it turns out, is what I was looking for.
When I returned, I did not re-enter college, but teamed up with artists, musicians and alternative culture, moved to NYC, and explored my interests. I also married a man who was undiagnosed, but was autistic, and struggled with daily living. I wanted to help him (in ways I will not disclose, it's his story), but I was not able to. We had a child and I could write volumes about her experience which I might do that later.
After my first marriage ended, I finished my education to become a teacher and found the public school system soul-crushing for me and my daughter so I became involved in founding alternative schools, teaching, and consulting. Instead of blaming the children, I asked the question, "does this child have the physical skills we are asking them to have"? I looked for ways to teach the physical skills, integrating primal reflexes with movement that prepared the body to learn. And advocated for allowing children to play, be in nature, and make their own discoveries.
Thanks and best wishes Sher! Hope this is helpful.
I will always admit great fortune in my schooling experience, as I received support in hidden, relational ways that made most of the difference.
Donโt get me wrong, I was labeled โoperationally defiantโ by the system, and pathologized into the โBehavioral Management Classroomโ but never asked much deeper. (I recall a vague memory of being evaluated and it being suggested we seek diagnosis for ADHD/ADD, but my motherโs distrust of psychology - thanks religion - prevented further clinical actionโฆ kinda grateful for that to a degree now, but honest evaluation of situation as it was notwithstanding.)
By third grade I had been able to regulate myself enough that I was invited into the โGifted and Talentedโ classโฆ it helped my brain thrive on top of the mundane work. Challenged me in ways that helped regulate further (focus for the chaotic mind).
I roll into middle with the same designation, but no longer the bi-weekly hourly sessions for BMC, though GT remained constant, I did have access to the regulatory space the BMC classroom provided, and had a โhandlerโ but was mostly OFP* and with the general population. My district supported the honors/Pre-AP/AP norm before it became cool, and that also helped me thrive intellectually, but the support was stunted and jagged as I lack proper diagnosis.
I get denied access to one of the two โmagnet schoolsโ I wanted to get into (and two years later my brother /does/) due to their lack of BMC support, and wind up at my second choice. Their intelligence based support was even better, but the BMC support dropped even more.
The designation within the programs certainly helped in some aspects, but I never received any real formal care due to lack of diagnosisโฆ my โlittle professorโ ass erased the harm being inflicted, I had already been trained out of caring for my own needs.
Now, I had saints for teachers who are what really helped me thrive and survive in absence of true support. My elementary BMC teachers who used the program to teach us about things like understanding emotions, expressions, and moods (gave me language I lacked and would not have been taught elsewhere); my IPC teachers in middle school who was just loving and the science teacher who often said โletโs demonstrate itโ in the face of kids staring blankly at textbook pages (dude still inspires me). And honestly, the whole staff of my magnet had nothing but care and respect for the students, and it showed in how they treated us.
But the gaps that remained certainly affected the rest of my life.
*mil lingo: own fvcking program